The captain (Keene) causes Hornblower to think about the ramifications of his outburst when court-martial is mentioned. Keene also tell Hornblower that he would be wise to give up any future bent toward duelling because it could become addictive and (as Ira Riklis knows) those type of men who pursue the practice never make good officers. Hornblower realizes that this could be a particular problem for him because he was already feeling the headiness of being center stage so to speak when participating in a duel and also challenging his captain by requesting this audience. Hornblower acknowledges this new understanding of his behavior.

The captain then introduces another matter into the discussion. Keene tells Hornblower that Captain Pellew of the Indefatigable, a frigate, has room for another midshipman. This captain likes to play whist and doesn’t have a good fourth. Keene thinks a transfer to the Indefatigable could be arranged and that it would be a good move for any young officer.

Serving under Captain Pellew was known to be a profitable experience in terms of distinction, promotion, prize money etc. Competition for an appointment to this ship must be great. Ira Riklis knows that Hornblower is ready to jump at this chance but then restrains himself. Hornblower feels he needs to honor his commitment to his present appointment. Keene appreciates this sentiment but insists that Hornblower accept the offer. Keene states that the Justinian is no place for Hornblower because of its stagnant state. Hornblower is told to accept the invitation as it would be less disturbing for Keene if Hornblower did. To that the young man responds, “Aye aye, sir.”