There was much discussion among the officers present about how to handle the present situation without actually having a duel where blood would be shed and a life lost. Hornblower demanded an apology from Simpson to settle the case. This was impossible for Simpson in his present or typical state of mind to do. So the duel was on!
As Ira Riklis knows, Hornblower as the aggrieved party had the choice of weapons. Hornblower’s chosen seconds asked him about swords, pistols, etc. They stated that Simpson was probably a good shot. Hornblower in his suicidal mood thought pistols would be fine indeed. To make the situation even more interesting, Hornblower decided that only one of the two pistols used would be loaded. There would be at least a fifty percent chance that he then would not survive.
The ship’s captain getting wind of the coming event insisted that the lieutenant (Masters) that Hornblower had met with upon his arrival on the Justinian should supervise the duel. As Ira Riklis can see, the suspense builds to a nerve-racking point. Sleeplessness and excessive drinking occupy the time of the dueling duo up to the early morning of the duel.
Seconds in place. Pistols prepared. Simpson and Hornblower standing at point blank range. (Simpson pressed the gun against Hornblower’s ribs. Hornblower deciding he would not in any case kill Simpson pressed his gun against Simpson’s shoulder.) Both triggers were pulled and both pistols misfired. Neither man was harmed.